e Menu © Overview =» NYC024329.aff4 (Evidence ID: NYC024329.aff4 - 001) © Case Data = Calendar Items Calls Messages Notes Top Contacts User Accounts Top Contacts Top Contact Source ¥C024329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device Path /Users/karyna/Library/Messages/Archive/2018-04-05/Chat with | Bonoroza et al on 2018-04-05 at 11.08.59.ichat Nn Address [x Count Total 31198 Count Messages Count Emails 0 Count Calls 0 HashID __ top_contacts:0:165 31198 Top Contact Source ¥C024329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device Path /Users/karyna/Library/Mail/V6/1B90A3EB-C561-4DB6-A847-27A656F 13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4 23B1948-4823-4372-8F 13-F70BCF7860A F/Data/6/8/Messages/86615.emlx Name _ karyna shuliak Address Count Total 28959 Count Messages Count Emails Count Calls 0 HashID — top_contacts:0:2224 28959 Top Contact Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD EFTA00518756

--=PAGE_BREAK=--

Path /Users/karyna/Library/Messages/Archive/20 18-07-13/Chat with Po et al on 20 18-07-13 at 09.55.56.ichat ae Address FY Count Total 22524 Count Messages Count Emails 0 Count Calls 0 HashID top _contacts:0:360 22524 Top Contact Source \¥C024329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device Path /Users/sarahk (Deleted)/Library/Mail/V2/Mac-sarahk525/Work.mbox/LSJ.mbox/5184DD6D-098 A-4810-977E-86 13 A4F7EC65/Data/0/4/1/Messages/140977.emlx Name [a Address Count Total 12304 Count Messages Count Emails Count Calls 0 HashID top _contacts:0:38 12304 Top Contact Source 1yC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device Path /Users/sarahk (Deleted)/Library/Mail/V2/Mac-sarahk525/Drafts.mbox/5 184DD6D-098A-48 10-9 77E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/9/0/1/Messages/ 109545 partial.emlx Name 2 Address Count Total 11431 Count Messages Count Emails Count Calls 0 HashID top _contacts:0:38 11431 Top Contact Source \¥¢024329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device Path /Users/karyna/Library/Mail/V6/1B90A3EB-C561-4DB6-A847-27A656F 13C1A/Junk.mbox/423 B1948-4823-4372-8F 13-F70BCF7860A F/Data/7/4/1/Messages/147677.emlx ae EFTA00518757

--=PAGE_BREAK=--

Address Count Total 10952 Count Messages Count Emails Count Calls 0 HashID _ top_contacts:0:2224 10952 Top Contact Source NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device Path /Users/sarahk (Deleted)/Library/Mail/V2/Mac-sarahk525/Drafts.mbox/5 184DD6D-098A-48 10-9 77E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/7/9/Messages/97 126.emlx ne Address Count Total 10714 Count Messages Count Emails Count Calls 0 HashID _ top_contacts:0:1698 10714 Top Contact Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD Path {U sers/karyna/Library/Messages/Archive/20 17-01-09/Chat with J et al on 2017-0 1-06 at 21.24.36.ichat Name | Address Count Total 9891 Count Messages Count Emails 0 Count Calls 0 HashID __top_contacts:0:409 9891 Top Contact Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD Path /U sers/karyna/Library/Messages/Archive/20 18-07-13/Chat with Po et al on 20 18-07-13 at 09.55.56.ichat we Address Count Total 9600 Count Messages Count Emails 0 9600 EFTA00518758

--=PAGE_BREAK=--

Count Calls 0 HashID _ top_contacts:0:40 Top Contact Source N'YC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device Path /Users/karyna/Library/Messages/Archive/2016-08-19/Chat with [EY Bonorosa et al on 2016-08-19 at 18.02.08.ichat Name Address FY Count Total 9572 Count Messages Count Emails 0 Count Calls 0 HashID __ top_contacts:0:184 9572 Top Contact pounce NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD Path /Users/sarahk (Deleted)/Library /Mail/V2/Mac -sarahk525/INBOX.mbox/5 184DD6D-098A-48 10- 97TE-8613A4F7EC65/Data/2/3/1/Messages/132832.emlx Name | | Address Count Total 8089 Count Messages Count Emails Count Calls 0 HashID _ top_contacts:0:38 8089 Top Contact Source \1yC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device Path /Users/sarahk (Deleted)/Library/Mail/V2/Mac-sarahk525/INBOX.mbox/5184DD6D-098A-48 10- 97TTE-8613A4F7EC65/Data/9/2/1/Messages/129032.emlx ae Address Count Total 7593 Count Messages Count Emails Count Calls 0 HashID _ top_contacts:0:38 7593 EFTA00518759

--=PAGE_BREAK=--

Top Contact Pouree NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD levice patn _ /Users/karyna/Library/Mail/V6/1B90A 3EB-C561-4DB6-A847-27A6S6F 13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4 23B1948-4823-4372-8F 13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/9/9/Messages/99076.partial.emlx Name KARYNA SHULIAK Address Count Total 7298 Count Messages Count Emails Count Calls 0 HashID _ top_contacts:0:1633 7298 Top Contact Source 024329. aff4/Macintosh HD Device Path /Users/sarahk (Deleted)/Library/Mail/V2/Mac-sarahk525/INBOX.mbox/5184DD6D-098A-48 10- 977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/9/2/1/Messages/129061.emlx Name __ jeffrey Epstein Address Count Total 5926 Count Messages Count Emails Count Calls 0 HashID top contacts:0:1669 5926 Top Contact Pounce NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD Path /Users/karyna/Library/Mail/V6/1 B90A3EB-C 561 -4DB6-A 847-27 A656F 13C1 A/INBOX.mbox/4 23B1948-4823-4372-8F 13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/7/9/Messages/97282.partial.emlx wae Address Count Total 5835 Count Messages Count Emails Count Calls 0 HashID _ top_contacts:0:1633 5835 Top Contact Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD EFTA00518760

--=PAGE_BREAK=--

/Users/karyna/Library/Messages/Archive/2016-10-12/EE on 2016-10-12 at 16.57.0 Path ae 4.ichat uu Address Count Total 4887 Count Messages Count Emails 0 Count Calls 0 HashID top_contacts:0:276 4887 Top Contact Source 1924329. aff4/Macintosh HD Device Path __Usets/karyna/Library/Mail/V6/1B90A3EB-C561-4DB6-A847-27A6S56F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4 23B1948-4823-4372-8F 13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/4/0/1/Messages/ 104609.emlx N»ne a Count Total 4323 Count Messages Count Emails Count Calls 0 HashID _ top_contacts:0:2279 4323 Top Contact Source 1024329. aff4/Macintosh HD Device Path /Users/sarahk (Deleted)/Library/Mail/V2/Mac-sarahk525/INBOX.mbox/5 1 84DD6D-098A-48 10- 977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/9/ Name Karina Shuliak Address Count Total 3004 Count Messages 2/1/Messages/129160.emlx Count Emails Count Calls 0 HashID top contacts:0:1633 3004 Top Contact Source 1024329. aff4/Macintosh HD Device Path /Users/sarahk (Deleted)/Library/Mail/V2/Mac-sarahk525/Drafts.mbox/5 184DD6D-098A-48 10-9 77E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/6/6/Messages/663 19.partial.emlx Name EFTA00518761

--=PAGE_BREAK=--

Count Total 2712 Count Messages Count Emails Count Calls 0 HashID _ top_contacts:0:2279 2712 Top Contact pource NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD Path /Users/karyna/Library/Mail/V6/1B90A3EB-C561 -ADB6-A847-2 7A656F 13C1LA/INBOX.mbox/4 23B1948-4823-4372-8F 13-F70BCF7860A F/Data/9/0/1/Messages/109535.emlx Name _ jeffrey E. Address —jeevacation(@gmail.com Count Total 2693 Count Messages Count Emails Count Calls 0 HashID _ top_contacts:0:1669 2693 Top Contact Source 1yC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device Path /U sers/karyna/Library/Mail/V6/ 1B9DA3EB-C561 -4DB6-A847-2 7A656F 13C1A/Sent Messages. mbox/423B 1948-4823-4372-8F 13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/8/7/Messages/78278.em1x Name _ jeffrey Address —jeevacation(@gmail.com Count Total 2575 Count Messages Count Emails Count Calls 0 HashID — top_contacts:0:1669 257 tn Top Contact pouree NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD Path /Users/sarahk (Deleted)/Library/Mail/V2/Mac-sarahk525/INBOX.mbox/5 184DD6D-098A-48 10- 977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/9/1/1/Messages/119768.em1x Name Richard Kahn Address Count Total 2515 EFTA00518762

--=PAGE_BREAK=--

Count Messages Count Emails Count Calls 0 HashID top contacts:0:284 tN in a Top Contact Source 1¥C024329.aff'4/Macintosh HD Device Path /Users/sarahk (Deleted)/Library/Mail/V2/Mac-sarahk525/INBOX.mbox/5 184DD6D-098A-48 10- 977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/0/5/1/Messages/150520.emlx Name Bella Klein Address Count Total 1924 Count Messages Count Emails Count Calls 0 HashID _ top_contacts:0:1452 1924 Top Contact Source 7yC024329.aff'4/Macintosh HD Device Path /Users/sarahk (Deleted)/Library/Mail/V2/Mac-sarahk525/Sent Messages.mbox/5184DD6D-098A -4810-977E-86 13 A4F7EC65/Data/9/4/Messages/49362.emlx Name Address Count Total 1893 Count Messages Count Emails Count Calls 0 HashID top _contacts:0:1108 1893 Top Contact Source 1024329. aff4/Macintosh HD Device Path /Users/sarahk (Deleted)/Library/Mail/V2/Mac-sarahk525/INBOX.mbox/5184DD6D-098A-48 10- 977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/9 Name Daphne Wallace Address Count Total 1870 Count Messages /1/Messages/139598.emlx EFTA00518763

--=PAGE_BREAK=--

Count Emails Count Calls 0 HashID _ top_contacts:0:282 1870 Top Contact Source 7024329. aff4/Macintosh HD Device Path /Users/sarahk (Deleted)/Library/Mail/V2/Mac-sarahk525/Junk.mbox/5184DD6D-098A-48 10-97 7E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/9/5/1/Messages/159002.emlx na Address Count Total 1785 Count Messages Count Emails Count Calls 0 HashID _ top_contacts:0:38 1785 Top Contact Source 1024329. aff4/Macintosh HD Device Path /Users/sarahk (Deleted)/Library/Mail/V2/Mac-sarahk525/INBOX.mbox/5 184DD6D-098A-48 10- 9TTE-8613A4F7ECO65/Data/9, we Address Count Total 1725 Count Messages Count Emails Count Calls 0 HashID _ top_contacts:0:1445 /1/Messages/139662.emlx 1725 Top Contact Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD /Users/karyna/Library/Messages/Archive/2017-09-04/Chat with Leo et al on 2017-08-25 at 11. 02.00.ichat Name Leo Address FY Count Total 1715 Count Messages Count Emails 0 Count Calls 0 HashID top_contacts:0:333 Path 1715 EFTA00518764

--=PAGE_BREAK=--

Top Contact Source 1y924329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device Path /Users/karyna/Library/Mail/V6/1B90A3EB-C561-4DB6-A847-27A656F 13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4 23B1948-4823-4372-8F 13-F70BCF7860A F/Data/9/2/1/Messages/129170.emlx Name Merwin Dela Cruz Adress Count Total 1616 Count Messages Count Emails Count Calls 0 HashID — top_contacts:0:1672 1616 Top Contact Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD /Users/karyna/Library/Messages/Archive/2017-10-06/Chat with Marilyn et al on 2017-10-06 at 09.27.25.ichat Name Sonam Address [x Count Total 1584 Count Messages Count Emails 0 Count Calls 0 HashID top_contacts:0:266 Path 1584 Top Contact Source 1024329. aff4/Macintosh HD Device Path /Users/sarahk (Deleted)/Library/Mail/V2/Mac-sarahk525/INBOX.mbox/5184DD6D-098A-48 10- 9TTE-8613A4F7EC65/Data/9, Name ann rodriquez Address Count Total 1555 Count '1/Messages/159864.emlx Messages 9 Count 1555 Emails i Count Calls 0 HashID _ top_contacts:0:2206 Top Contact Source . NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device EFTA00518765

--=PAGE_BREAK=--

/Users/sarahk (Deleted)/Library/Mail/V2/Mac-sarahk525/INBOX.mbox/5 184DD6D-098A-48 10- 977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/9/2/1/Messages/129160.em1x Name _ Jojo fontanilla Adress Count Total 1458 Count Messages Count Emails Count Calls 0 HashID _ top_contacts:0:1686 Path 1458 Top Contact Source 1¢024329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device Path /Users/sarahk (Deleted)/Library/Mail/V2/Mac-sarahk525/Work.mbox/LSJ.mbox/5184DD6D-098 A-4810-977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/0/4/1/Messages/140972.partial.emlx ae Address Count Total 1337 Count Messages Count Emails Count Calls 0 HashID top _contacts:0:38 1337 Top Contact Source 1¥¢024329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device Path __Usets/karyna/Library/Mail/V6/1B90A3EB-C561-4DB6-A847-27A6S6F 13C1 A/INBOX.mbox/4 23B1948-4823-4372-8F 13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/0/9/Messages/90226.partial.emlx nu Address Count Total 1241 Count Messages Count Emails Count Calls 0 HashID _ top_contacts:0:2247 1241 Top Contact Source NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device /Users/sarahk (Deleted)/Library/Mail/V2/Mac-sarahk525/Junk.mbox/5 184DD6D-098A-48 10-97 = 7E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/9/5/1/Messages/159096.emlx EFTA00518766

--=PAGE_BREAK=--

Name DailyCandy Address Count Total 1219 Count Messages Count Emails Count Calls 0 HashID top contacts:0:11423 1219 EFTA00518767